Monocle, please open source code and release on github



  • It is clear that Monocle as it stands is dead. No updates, doesn’t work, no discussions on forum (because there is nothing us poor users can do without the devs), and the forum spam is ramping unabated. Monocle is dead.

    But it doesn’t have to be. Monocle devs, since you’ve gotten bored with the project, but since it is actually superbly useful and needed, please just open source license everything and post what you have organized best you can on GitHub so that someone else can have a run at it. Since there are costs to running it, allow the OS licence to branch commercially.



  • @Lexx
    Hey, the dev is a good guy and does what he can to assist and also update Monocle. Many users have had success and it does work!
    It would be nice to have it open source and I understand where you come from.
    Let’s see what he says…



  • This is the best product ever! If you need help, I will be glad to assist. I have used this code since the beginning and it works.



  • @vmsman Ok, thanks, here is my unanswered thread, for example, but the forum is full of people with problems talking to themselves (and spam):

    https://forum.monoclecam.com/topic/832/help-setting-up-chortau-onvif-camera-for-echo-show-8

    Actually I’ve now removed Monocle Gateway from my Docker server since it was useless. But if there is to be progress, I can re-do everything. I sincerely appreciate the help, but I strongly suspect that solutions will require software updates and the devs are MIA.



  • What works, works well. Judging from logs and discussions, what doesn’t work is generally due to Alexa being fussy about something and closing the stream. I agree that it’s disappointing that there’s nothing ongoing, but I’m sure they’d be glad to give me double my purchase price back. 😉



  • @mudgen said in Monocle, please open source code and release on github:

    I’m sure they’d be glad to give me double my purchase price back. 😉

    Is the point that free should be useless? Anyways, this is why I requested open sourcing, so that the community can make it work when it doesn’t since free is usually insufficient motivation for creators.



  • No, the point is that it is far from useless in spite of Google’s capricious API behaviors. I did not mean to disparage the notion of open sourcing.



  • @mudgen Alexa is very fussy with cameras. The Monocle gateway does exactly what it needs to, but the solution can be very one-off per model number of camera. I have mostly Reolink cameras, a GW Gateway camera and an Amcrest camera. I have all these cameras working on my Echo 10" 2ng Gens and on my Fire TV 4k sticks. I have one Echo Show 8 and only the GW Gateway works on it. In general, the Monocle Gateway is awesome. The Alexa camera and device support are not designed to support other than their skill supported cameras. I had three Wyze cameras working great and two months ago the Wyze Alexa skill refused to display them despite no changes.



  • @vmsman While I appreciate and understand the context, this doesn’t move the problem forward at all (unless the intent is to say “move along, it’ll never work”, a conclusion I can reach on my own).

    However, I am able and willing to work with a/the developer to try to make it work and I have the capability to do some further reverse engineering (packet capture on my network, etc) on the cameras and/or Alexa devices if there is a will and availability of starting points (I have neither the interest nor time to completely re-invent the wheel, at least not yet).

    So, where is this developer in this discussion then?



  • Robert is the developer and he is a good guy. Perhaps he will chime in.



  • I’ve used Monocle for nearly 4 yrs - and haven’t had anything but great luck and success. I don’t blame my wants and needs on Monocle, the opposite. I’m grateful it works.

    Recently I had problems with new hardware and couldn’t solve. Today I found another user had solved. I’m happy and pleased.
    I say all this because I don’t think Monocle should be Open Source. It would become just a sludgepool of support requests to solve different camera models. There are already numerous Open Source Proxies that could be modified if thats the desire. In my opinion, specific solutions work well in Open Source, but NOT when it’s a wide spread application with the potential of monetization. And lets not forget, it seems pretty common knowledge most of what I see are related to Amazon’s problems with Show models/versions.



  • @jshimota Well stated and very eloquent points.



  • Perhaps if the developer would allow a community moderator just to keep on top of the spam? I’m sure that would address most of the issues.

    I think in part the reason that there isn’t much development is because in the majority of cases it just works. For a free skill that displays almost any camera that already puts it ahead of 1000s of other Alexa skills I have used 😂



  • @michael : A community moderator or two might help us to be more of a community to each other, pointing out esoteric clues in log traces and remarking on obscure config tweaks and such.



  • @mudgen
    Agree there… got an email this morning for a forum update, 5 spam topics and two genuine ones. Might be dipping out of this continues…


Log in to reply